Adjudicators Report - Observations by LTTA
Some further observations from LLTA arising from the adjudicators' report on Leixlip in he 2007 Tidy Town Competition.
Observations on adjudicators' report on Leixlip in he 2007 Tidy Town Competition
1) Amongst the 18 towns in Leixlip’s size category, we came 10th in the ranking, up one place on last year. The best town was Ennis, which scored an average of 74%, compared to our 63%. If the areas within the control of Kildare County Council or Leixlip Town Council (ie, Waste Minimisation, Litter Control, Tidiness, and the Built Environment) matched the marks obtained for areas mainly within our scope, we would have risen to 4th place in the competition, putting us on a par with Carlow town, which scored 275 marks.
2) Our weakest area were judged to be in Waste Minimisation (40%), followed by Litter Control. “The committee makes a strong case for the provision of recycling facilities in the car parks of supermarkets” - said the judges. They were referring to our attempt get the town council to make a by-law requiring stores which sell goods in recyclable packaging to provide recycling facilities at their premises. We got zilch – not even a reply. Instead the town council demanded the closure of bottle/can banks for the slightest problem; instead they should have provided more and kept them clean from their own resources. Leixlip’s recyclables have gone down because of the closure of facilities, according to the Co Council’s own data.
3) The second worst area was in Litter Control (46%): The judges commented: “On the day of adjudication, the town centre was quite littered particularly along the main street and at the Plaza and the car park behind.” The report states that the judging took place on Tuesday, 19th June last. It didn’t! We know that two judges with clipboards were about on the Monday, 11th June, during the day and probably the previous Saturday, 9th. We do our cleanups mostly on Monday evenings. They would have picked up the week end litter from the pubs and takeaways. Street cleansing is mainly the job of Kildare Co Council; but is also the job the Macaris and others whose customers cause litter: they are required to clean up on each side of their premises. The implementation of the litter and the planning laws is also KCC’s job. The Gardai have powers to issue on the spot fines for litter. Where are they when they are needed? In our cleansing work the village centre and surrounding areas are peppered with drink bottles and cans - when drinking alcohol in public is against the town bylaws - and cartons from Route 66, Sam’s takeaway, McDonalds (Lucan) and the newest takeaway premises on Main St, Subway. We have already reported that the Co Council’s spending on street cleansing is haphazard and has been cut back in reality. The control of opening hours is still a case of all talk and no action. The approach roads from Lucan (in South Co Dublin’s area) and from Maynooth are way below par and we are surprised that the judges did not comment on them.
4) The Built Environment is our next weakest area, with 56% of the possible marks. The control of the too many shopfront signs, especially outside the Spar shop and the estate agents next door - about which the judges were critical is a planning control matter most suited to Kildare Co Council, but they won’t do it, so it is beyond control. The town council, as a statutory representative body, has the resources and authority to pursue by several means the removal of excessive signage, and the ugly electricity meters and brackets erected for one-week-a-year festival and Christmas season which deface the town centre all the year round; these are grant-aided by the town council, which should see that the place is not permanently spoiled by them.
5) We are very pleased that our efforts at landscaping, assisted by those of the Co Council’s new Parks’ Superintendent, have been rewarded. We won 70% of the possible marks and kudos for our planted half-barrels, beds at Easton and Confey GAA, the Rye bank etc; so too did the town council for its tubs and window boxes on the main street. We expect to do better here next year as our planting schemes mature.
